Hello dear
Welcome To Serafina’s Pizzeria
At Serafina’s Pizzeria, we craft authentic Italian fare that honors the spirit of New York pizza. Nestled in St. Johns, FL, our pizzeria is renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and dedicated service. We offer a delicious array of pizzas, including buffalo chicken and supreme variations, along with mouthwatering garlic knots. Our commitment to quality shines through every slice, with a focus on fresh ingredients. Enjoy the warmth of heated outdoor seating, or take advantage of our delivery and takeout options. Join us for happy hour specials, and experience why Serafina’s is becoming a local favorite for pizza lovers.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Beef Patty
$4.00Combo Calzone
Zeppole
Cheesecake
Pepperoni Calzone
Philly Cheese Steak
Chicken Parm 12 Hero
Eggplant Parm 12 Hero
House Salad
About
Serafina’s Pizzeria
Welcome to Serafina’s Pizzeria, where the heart of Italy meets the soul of St. Johns, FL. Nestled conveniently at 4125 Race Track Rd, this establishment offers a delightful menu that celebrates traditional Italian cuisine, specializing in mouthwatering pizzas and succulent chicken wings. With a casual atmosphere that’s perfect for family dinners or a night out with friends, Serafina’s is quickly becoming a beloved spot in the local community.
At Serafina’s, you can expect more than just standard pizzas. The culinary team crafts each dish with care, embodying the classic flavors of New York pizza, beloved by locals and newcomers alike. Reviews highlight the buffalo chicken pizza and garlic knots as standout favorites, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality ingredients and flavorful pairings. For those craving variety, the menu also boasts many vegetarian options, ensuring that everyone finds something to delight their palate.
- Location: 4125 Race Track Rd Ste 106, St Johns, FL 32259
- Phone: (904) 217-7310
- Services: Delivery, Takeout, Reservations, Catering, Outdoor Seating
- Accessibility: Wheelchair Accessible, ADA-Compliant Main Entrance
- Atmosphere: Casual, Moderate Noise, Family-Friendly
- Credit Options: Accepts Credit Cards and Cryptocurrency
Customer experiences reflect a commitment to excellence. Grace H. raves about the attentive service alongside her tasty buffalo chicken pizza, emphasizing that it’s not just about the food; it’s also about the entire dining experience. Meanwhile, Joyce S. shares her satisfaction with the supreme pizza, although with a note on the crust texture, which indicates the staff's dedication to continually refining their offerings.
One of the unique offerings at Serafina’s is their array of takeout and delivery options, catering to your pizza cravings whether you're dining in or enjoying a cozy night at home. If you’re a fan of good beer and wine pairings with your meal, you’ll be pleased to find that they serve these as well, enhancing your dining experience further.
Serafina’s Pizzeria is not just another eatery; it’s a place that embodies the love for Italian cuisine, providing a space where flavors thrive and patrons feel welcome. The dog-friendly patio and heated outdoor seating options make this pizzeria the perfect spot for every season. Whether you’re grabbing a giant slice post-game or indulging in a full meal with the family, Serafina’s Pizzeria is where good food and great company come together.
In a world of pizza choices, remember Serafina's is more than just a meal—it's a culinary experience waiting to be savored. Come for the pizza, stay for the memories!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great food and service! Everyone was attentive and buffalo chicken pizza and garlic knots were great ”
“ My husband and I picked up a supreme pizza, which has pepperoni, jalapeño (added on), mushroom, bell peppers, and onions. It was delicious! Served very hot so still warm by the time we got home. The crust was very tasty at the ends but wimbly at the other end. I would have liked to be crustier so you can hold it without it falling apart. ”
“ These guys make some original New York pizza. And it's really good. They sell giant slices too. There is room for maybe 20 customers at their tables and the service is fast and friendly. They tend to be a the higher range of cost per pizza but in this case you do get what you paid for! ”
“ Missing ingredients! Ordered a 18 inch Sicilian Margherita with anchovies and chicken toppings, it came with no basil which was supposed to be there; and they ran out of anchovies but didn't say anything until the pie was already made, also put on very few pieces of chicken. The pizza not look anything like the pictures at all, looked like something from papa johns. I expect better for a near $40 pie! Edit: Fortunately, they have refunded without my asking. ”
“ Solid slice! Overall great tasting from the sauce to the cheese to the crust. This makes stop 3 on our local mini pizza tour. Definitely comparable to a decent NY slice. And yes, I know pizza, born and raised in Queens. ”
“ We were looking for authentic NY style pizza, and we found it! We've had a few different apps with pizza and everything has been delicious. There is a few for purchases made with a credit card. The ambiance is 'Everything NY, Staten Island, etc. ' ”
“ Food & Service...both 5 STARS. This is Brooklyn Pizza...as a NYr, I often crave NY pizza, wings and calzones, etc. This pizzeria is second to none. Food is always fresh... Thanks Christina & husband for making my family feel welcomed. Dan ”
“ LOVE this NY pizza place! Best pizza place I've found since moving to FL. The dough is thin but not too thin, perfect to fold and shovel in! Sauce is super tasty and I love getting the pizza with spicy pepperoni and jalapeño. Also tried their sub and it's super filling and delicious. This is my go-to pizza joint! I usually order to go but eaten inside a couple of times. The place is small but there are a few seats. Clean and very much reminds you of NY! Staff is very friendly and efficient. You must try! ”
